The Atlanta Five

^{The Pensacola Journal | December 14, 1974}

In late November 1974, what began as a routine fishing excursion became a haunting mystery for Atlanta and Pensacola, lingering for years. Lee Roy Holloway, Robert Walker, Marvin Walker, John Sterling, and Lonnie Merritt, five Black American men, embarked on a fishing journey to Pensacola, Florida. They never made it back. Their deserted boat was eventually found, and their bodies were recovered amidst a cloud of unresolved queries and profound grief.

The “Atlanta Five” became a symbol of the dangers that Black Americans faced in the South, their untimely deaths igniting widespread anger and skepticism. Their families and communities have been left in a relentless pursuit of the truth. This case stands as a stark testament to the treacherous conditions of the time and still prompts significant inquiries about justice and responsibility.

Background Information
The Disappearance
Theories and Speculations
Community Impact
Current Status of the Case
Conclusion
FAQs
Sources

Background Information

The Atlanta Five refers to five African American men from Atlanta, Georgia, whose tragic destinies are still shrouded in mystery. Their story is a poignant reminder of unresolved cases that continue to stir questions and seek closure.

Lee Roy Holloway: A 39-year-old, military veteran and warehouse worker for Colonial Foods. He was an experienced fisherman with more than two decades on the water.
Robert Walker: 59 years old, and the owner of the motorboat. He was a good swimmer and an experienced fisherman. He was employed by Colonial Foods, and he was one of the top mechanics, and a member of the local Teamsters Union.
Marvin Walker: At 66, he was the oldest of the group. He was retired from the Atlanta School System.
John Sterling: 46 years old, and an employee of Colonial Foods.
Lonnie Merritt: 49 years old, and an employee of Colonial Foods.

On November 29, 1974, these men set out on a fishing trip to Pensacola, Florida with the intent to return on December 2, 1974. Their journey took a tragic turn when their boat was discovered deserted, and their bodies were eventually found, sparking widespread speculation and unanswered questions regarding the events that led to their demise.

The Disappearance

The lead-up to the vanishing of the Atlanta Five started off as nothing out of the ordinary. Lee Roy Holloway, Robert Walker, Marvin Walker, John Sterling, and Lonnie Merritt were gearing up for their usual weekend fishing getaway to Pensacola, Florida. With their boat filled with provisions, ice, tackle, and bait, they embarked towards the Santa Rosa Sound, ready for what was supposed to be a familiar expedition.

However, the men never returned as anticipated. On November 30, 1974 at about 10 a.m., Robert Walker’s son was informed his father’s boat had been found abandoned in the Santa Rosa Sound. The anchor line had been cut, life jackets lay unused, and the ignition key was in the on position. Nearby, a camper contained their supplies, ice, fishing gear, and bait, yet there was no sign of the men themselves. The mysterious abandonment of the boat immediately sparked speculation and concern.

A witness observed a heated argument between the men and John Simms, the owner of a bait shop in Pensacola. According to that witness, Simms made life-threatening remarks towards at least one of the men. This altercation is one of the few documented interactions they had with locals before they went missing.

^{Atlanta Journal Constitution | December 20, 1974}

The Atlanta Five incident has left families with deep sorrow and many unanswered questions. Even with ongoing investigations, the exact circumstances of their passing remain a mystery, leaving families and the community seeking closure and justice. Rev. H.K Matthews was a key figure in investigating the incident and supporting the families of the Atlanta Five. At that time, Rev. Matthews was a prominent civil rights figure and led the local Southern Christian Leadership Conference (SCLC) chapter.

The investigation into the Atlanta Five’s disappearance kicked off as soon as their empty boat was discovered in the Santa Rosa Sound. The U.S. Coast Guard alongside the Sheriff’s Office scoured the vicinity, yet the men’s bodies remained elusive. To unravel the mystery, authorities initiated a thorough probe, which encompassed questioning the locals and scrutinizing the boat for any signs of what might have transpired.

Marvin Walker’s body was the first to be discovered on December 9, 1974. Three days, John Sterling and Robert Walker were retrieved from the water. Following a 14-day search, Lee Roy Holloway and Lonnie Merritt were the final two to be located, found mere hours apart on December 13, 1974.

Theories and Speculations

The prevailing theory is that the men perished in turbulent waters, yet this is disputed given their expertise as fishermen and the improbability of them lacking life jackets or gear. The possibility that they were racially targeted has been raised, fueled by an altercation with bait shop owner John Simms and subsequent threats. This has sparked conjecture that they fell victim to an assault and that their vessel was sabotaged.

Theories suggest the incident was concealed to prevent negative publicity or legal issues. Family members and civil rights advocates argue that the investigation was insufficient and that the truth remains obscured. Over time, numerous rumors and stories have emerged, yet none have offered solid proof. The condition of the bodies, reportedly well-preserved after a prolonged time in water, further deepens the mystery.

Community Impact

The event ignited widespread anger and worry among the Black American community and others. Civil rights figures like Rev. H.K. Matthews and Ralph Abernathy stepped in, calling for a complete investigation and justice for the affected families. In the face of tragedy, the community united in grief and unity, as loved ones pursued answers and peace.

The case of the Atlanta Five garnered extensive media attention, especially in Atlanta and Pensacola. Local newspapers and TV news frequently covered the story, highlighting the enigmatic nature of their demise. As time passed, the media periodically revisited the case, producing documentaries and articles that delved into the lingering mysteries and the profound effects on the families and communities affected.

Current Status of the Case

The Atlanta Five case still stands unsolved, stirring ongoing interest and conjecture. The victims’ families persist in their quest for clarity and justice. Despite numerous probes and conjectures, a conclusive resolution eludes us, leaving the precise details of their demise enigmatic.

The victims’ families have persistently sought answers and justice. They’ve engaged in interviews, public events, and advocacy campaigns to maintain momentum and strive for closure. Recently, there’s been a push to re-evaluate the evidence and revisit the case. Back in 2019, Atlanta’s then-Mayor Keisha Lance Bottoms, along with other officials, called on law enforcement to reassess the evidence to uncover any new leads.

Several civil rights leaders persist in their pursuit of justice for the Atlanta Five. Reverend Matthews remains a steadfast supporter for the affected families, advocating for a comprehensive investigation and justice. Georgia Congresswoman Nikema Williams, who succeeded the late Representative John Lewis, is actively involved in the case. Additionally, Gerald Griggs, the President of the Georgia NAACP, has been outspoken about the necessity for justice in this matter.

These leaders, together with activists and community members, are dedicated to maintaining public awareness of the case and pursuing answers for the victims’ families.

“We are not questioning the cause of death, but we are interested in the circumstances that may have contributed to the accident.” – Rev. H.K. Matthews

Conclusion

The Atlanta Five case still casts a shadow over America’s history of racial strife and injustice. Time has passed, yet the families of Lee Roy Holloway, Robert Walker, Marvin Walker, John Sterling, and Lonnie Merritt persist in their quest for clarity and justice. The suspicious nature of their demise, coupled with witness testimonies and the various theories that have surfaced, highlight the intricate difficulties and obstacles that Black Americans encountered in the South in the 1970s.

The quest for truth and resolution reflects the unyielding nature of the human spirit and the continuous search for justice. The narrative of the Atlanta Five is a powerful testament to the need for vigilance, advocacy, and solidarity when confronting challenges. In commemorating the Atlanta Five, we pay tribute to their legacy and support the persistent endeavors to reveal the truth and secure justice for their loved ones and communities.

Frequently asked questions about the Atlanta Five

Who were the Atlanta Five? The Atlanta Five, consisting of Lee Roy Holloway, Robert Walker, Marvin Walker, John Sterling, and Lonnie Merritt, were five Black American men who vanished on November 21, 1974, during a fishing expedition to Pensacola, Florida. Their empty boat was located the following day, and their bodies were found approximately a week to two weeks afterward. The mystery of their deaths is still unresolved, fueling a range of theories and continuous calls for justice.
What are the most popular theories about their disappearance? The prevailing theories surrounding the vanishing of the Atlanta Five include accidental drowning, a racially motivated assault, and a cover-up to dodge negative attention or legal repercussions.
Is the case still open? Indeed, the Atlanta Five case remains active. Despite extensive investigations and the involvement of law enforcement and civil rights advocates, the mystery persists, leaving families in search of closure and justice.
How has the community responded to this tragedy? The reaction of the community to the Atlanta Five tragedy has been marked by outrage, grief, and unity. Civil rights leaders and activists have strongly called for justice and a comprehensive investigation. The Black American community, both in Atlanta and elsewhere, has united to offer support to the victims’ families, in pursuit of answers and closure.
What steps are being taken to solve this case today? Current efforts to resolve the Atlanta Five case encompass persistent advocacy from civil rights leaders, intermittent media attention, and demands for re-evaluating the evidence with contemporary technology. In 2019, former Mayor Keisha Lance Bottoms called for a fresh review of the evidence by law enforcement, and there has been talk of employing DNA analysis and other forensic breakthroughs to discover new leads.

Sources

Butler, J. Michael. Beyond Integration: The Black Freedom Struggle in Escambia County, Florida, 1960-1980. United States: University of North Carolina Press, 2016.
“Atlanta Five Pensacola Deaths Revisited.” Pensacola News Journal. January 2, 2016. https://www.pnj.com/story/news/crime/2016/01/02/atlanta-five-pensacola-deaths-revisited/78126806/
“Statement in Support of Pensacola Murder Victims.” Cold Case Justice Initiative. June 29, 2015. https://coldcaselaw.syr.edu/2015/06/29/support-pensacola-murder-victims/
“The Atlanta Five | 1974 Kidnapping, Torture & Unsolved Murders of Five Atlanta Fishermen in Pensacola Florida.” 2015. https://web.archive.org/web/20150311160719/http://www.atlantafive.com/.
“50 Years Ago… – the Atlanta Five – Injustice Beneath the Surface | Facebook.” April 1, 2024. https://www.facebook.com/atlantafive/posts/pfbid0AsH7SeCmDhNJveEpu9zoZzKWoF9qiozzvH8ApcBfpXPY1ykGMgtvaYNg7AgbW1hQl.
Barrineau, Mary and Cox, Carolyn. “Abernathy: 3 Deaths ‘Foul Play”. The Pensacola Journal. December 13, 1974.
Moore, Colin. “Pensacolian Told Anglers Overloaded Boat Risky”. The Pensacola Journal. December 13, 1974.
“2 Bodies Found; SCLC in Search”. The Pensacola News. December 1974.
Coulter, Mike. “Victims’ Boat ‘Overloaded'”. The Pensacola News. December 1974.
Cox, Carolyn. “Matthews Takes Softer Stand on Drownings”. Pensacola News Journal. December 16, 1974.
Coulter, Mike. “Matthews: Questions Unanswered”. The Pensacola News. December 17, 1974.
Andrews, Harold 4X. “Death Of 5 Black Men Still Remain A Mystery”. The Atlanta Journal Constitution. December 1974
Joyce, Fay S. “SCLC To Seek Bodies”. The Atlanta Constitution. December 12, 1974.
Allen, Frederick. “Last 2 Bodies of 5 Fishermen Found”. The Atlanta Constitution. December 14, 1974.
Bell, Chuck. “‘No Hope’ for Five Atlantans”. The Atlanta Constitution. December 3, 1974.
Huey, John. “Mystery of Missing Boaters Deepens”. The Atlanta Constitution. December 4, 1974.
Norman, Jim. “The Drownings: Atlanta to the Gulf: Accident? Murder? Fiction?”. News Journal. January 19, 1975.
Cox, Carolyn. “Their Mission Is To Search, Their Goal Is To Find”. The Pensacola Journal. December 14, 1974.
Cox, Carolyn. “Autopsies Show No Foul Play”. The Pensacola Journal. December 1974.
Cox, Carolyn. “Volunteers Find 2 Missing Bodies”. The Pensacola Journal. December 14, 1974
“May Have Been Deceived – Abernathy”. The Pensacola News. December 19, 1974.
Dunwoody, Dave. 2021. “Matthews: ‘Black History Is America’s History.’” WUWF, February 26, 2021. https://www.wuwf.org/local-news/2021-02-26/matthews-black-history-is-americas-history.
“SCLC Investigating Deaths of Five Black Fisherman Believed to Be Murdered.” December 17, 1974. Civil Rights Digital Library. https://crdl.usg.edu/record/ugabma_wsbn_wsbn00595.
Staff, Fusion. 2015. “Cold Case Justice: Inside the Hunt for Civil Rights Era Killers.” Splinter. December 16, 2015. https://www.splinter.com/cold-case-justice-inside-the-hunt-for-civil-rights-era-1793853584.
Times, New York. 1975. “GOV. CARTER GIVEN DATA ON 5 DEATHS.” The New York Times, January 6, 1975. https://www.nytimes.com/1975/01/06/archives/gov-carter-given-data-on-5-deaths-families-and-sclc-say-blacks-who.html.